Math Caching and Immediately Useful Teaching Data
Last July, I posted a video in which I showed how to create a local, customized version of the Math Caching activity that can be found here.
I was inspired to revisit the idea last weekend reading Dan Meyer’s post about teacher dashboards. The part that got me thinking, and that stoked the fire that has been going in my head for a while, is identifying the information that is most useful to teachers. There are common errors that an experienced teacher knows to expect, but a new teacher may not recognize is common until it is too late. Getting a measure of wrong answers, and more importantly, the origin of those wrong answers, is where we ideally should be making the most of the technology in our (and the students’) hands. Anything that streamlines the process of getting a teacher to see the details of what students are doing incorrectly (and not just that they are getting something wrong) is valuable. The only way I get this information is by looking at student work. I need to get my hands on student responses as quickly as I can to make sense of what they are thinking.
As we were closing in on the end of an algebra review unit with the ninth graders this week, I realized that the math cache concept was good and fun and at a minimum was a remastering of the review sheet for a one-to-one laptop classroom. I came up with a number of questions and loaded it into the Python program. When one of my Calculus students stopped in to chat, and I showed her what I had put together, I told her that I was thinking of adding a step where students had to upload a screenshot of their written work in addition to entering their answer into the location box. She stared at me and said blankly: ‘You absolutely have to do that. They’ll cheat otherwise.’
While I was a bit more optimistic, I’m glad that I took the extra time to add an upload button on the page. I configured the program so that each image that was uploaded was also labeled with the answer that the student entered into the box. This way, given that I knew what the correct answers were, I knew which images I might want to look at to know what students were getting wrong.
This was pure gold.
Material like this was quickly filling up the image directory, and I watched it happening. I immediately knew which students I needed to have a conversation with. The answers ranged from ‘no solution’ to ‘identity’ to ‘x = 0’ and I instantly had material to start a conversation with the class. Furthermore, I didn’t need to throw out the tragically predictable ‘who wants to share their work’ to a class of students that don’t tend to want to share for all sorts of valid reasons. I didn’t have to cold call a student to reluctantly show what he or she did for the problem. I had their work and could hand pick what I wanted to share with the class while maintaining their anonymity. We could quickly look at multiple students’ work and talk about the positive aspects of each one, while highlighting ways to make it even better.
In this problem, we had a fantastic discussion about communicating both reasoning and process:
The next step that I’d like to make is to have this process of seeing all of the responses be even more transparent. I’d like to see student work popping up in a gallery that I can browse and choose certain responses to share with the class. Another option to pursue is to get students seeing the responses of their peers and offer advice.
Automatic grading certainly makes the job of answering the right/wrong question much easier. Sometimes a student does need to know whether an answer is correct or not. Given all the ways that a student could game the system (some students did discuss using Wolfram Alpha during the activity) the informative part on the teaching and assessment end is seeing the work itself. This is also an easy source of material for discussion with other teachers about student work (such as with Michael Pershan’s Math Mistakes).
I was blown away with how my crude hack to add this feature this morning made the class period a much richer opportunity to get students sharing and talking about their work. Now I’m excited to work on the next iteration of this idea.
This is dope as hell, Evan. Two follow ups:
One, what 1:1 tech are your students using?
Two, what do you mean by this:
“The next step that I’d like to make is to have this process of seeing all of the responses be even more transparent.”
Hey Dan, thanks for the comment!
My students all have Macbooks of one species or another.
That comment is about the fact that at the moment, looking at student responses involves browsing through images in a directory. Given the way I threw this together, this system was good enough for the moment during class.
I want to get rid of that intermediate step. As a teacher, I want to see all the student responses on a single page, flag the ones I want to show the class, and then have a nice full screen slide show that flips through those flagged images one by one. I might also want the option to automatically generate an images with all of the flagged images visible simultaneously.
In short, I’m being greedy. I’ve taken a lot out of the process of gathering work and I think I can make it even smoother. In one step, I want to aggregate, filter, and then display student work. I think I see how I might do this in code, but some other projects might push that to a bit later on this month.
Some slick work here Evan. This is something that I toyed around with, but never quite worked out exactly what I wanted.
Thanks Dave – are you referring to the question/chat app from last spring? That was great stuff. I’d love to have a gallery of responses to highlight and share with the class once it has all been collected – yours had that feature. This was just a quick hack that I now see has to be included in a more elegant way in my classroom apps in the future.
I believe (but have not tried) you can upload images in Polleverywhere.com responses?
I tried it once – the speed issues running this (and socrative.com) from China make it unusable. It’s possible this is also a China Great Firewall issue given other things that have been blocked.
There are tons of tools out there that have features that do this sort of thing, but the blocking requires that I come up with my own local solutions.
I hate to be ignorant but how are your students capturing their images? Are they just using the camera on the computer?
Yeah, just using their built in laptop camera. Not ideal in terms of image quality, does the job. Since this is just a locally hosted web app, they could just as easily upload from their phones through a browser, which I might insist upon moving forward.
Hi Evan, thanks for this. Great.
“The only way I get this information is by looking at student work.”
1. “The only way.” I wonder: could you have predicted that some kids would have said zero, some identity, and so on? Or was it a complete surprise? Trying to process how to anticipate student misconceptions and more efficiently expose them.
2. There’s “my favorite no,” which seems to get at what you’re writing about here?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rulmok_9HVs
Hi Sean,
It certainly isn’t the only way – I’ve seen students working on algebra long enough to know that I’d get all three responses(identity, no solution, x = 0). There’s something great about showing these things in work that was generated in the room, during the class period though. I’ve done the whole ‘I’ve seen this mistake before’ thing where I put up the mistake and ask students to respond and explain what’s wrong with it, but it never seems to hit the crowd as well as work that came from the students themselves.
As for ‘My favorite no’, I had never heard about it until I very recently. I knew my idea wasn’t original. I’m glad to know there’s a great name (and online following) for that activity already out there. I’ll definitely include this fully formed activity in future classes.
Thanks for your comments!
I was intrigued by your idea as I have been trying something similar to gather the data of my student’s work as they complete a quiz or exam. My method is to use a duplex scanner that students put their work into, press the button, and it is scanned into dropbox folder. I can review work electronically as it is completed by the students or later if I wish.
Hi,
I like this, but it’s too time consuming for me with one scanner. For individual students sending me their work outside of class, a single scanner works just fine. When I’m trying to look for good stuff to show the class though, having them all send simultaneously reduces that dead time of waiting or lining up at the scanner to submit their work.
Thanks for sharing.
Evan, I really like this and was wondering if there was a way to have students send pictures of their work simply from a worksheet instead of the online component or an online assignment from Edmodo, for example. I would like to start collecting their work on the fly even before I get so technological with them. FYI our district is going 1 to 1 with ipads in 2 weeks.
Hi Shannon,
I had students snap pictures of their work in their own notebooks, so there’s no reason you couldn’t have them submit from a worksheet that you provide. There are apps on iPad that help do this – check out Cathy Yenca’s post about nearpod here: here. There are others. I use my own programs primarily because many of the other online solutions work slowly when accessing them from China. There is other stuff available. Let me know how it goes for you.
Is the problem you have in the first graphic the one that goes with this student work?
Oops, I guess I am referring to the second graphic…Looks like the problem from the first graphic is the one that is supposed to go with the student work in the second?
Hi Matthew (which I can only assume is your name from your awesome name there),
Are you referring to the graphic on my page or Dan’s? The question on adding polynomials doesn’t have any student examples up on my post. The student work in the two images in the post was given in response to the question just above it in the image.